England's World Cup campaign ended in heartbreak as Argentina came from behind to win 2-1 in the semi-final. Thomas Tuchel's side were just five minutes from a first final since 1966 before a tactical switch invited pressure and ultimately defeat. Here are the big questions facing the manager and his squad.
Did Tuchel's tactical change cost England?
Leading 1-0 through Anthony Gordon's goal, Tuchel opted to switch to a back five in the 72nd minute, introducing Ezri Konsa for the goalscorer. The move was designed to protect the lead but instead handed the initiative to Argentina. The world champions threw on more forwards, and England retreated deeper until Enzo Fernandez and Lautaro Martinez struck. Tuchel later admitted he did not expect England to go so deep, but the decision to abandon a back four will haunt him.
What happened to the promise of a braver England?
When Tuchel replaced Gareth Southgate, he criticised the team for playing with fear in the European Championship final defeat to Spain. "They were more afraid to drop out of the tournament than having the hunger and excitement to win it," Tuchel said. He vowed a more front-footed, aggressive England. At times, that was evident, particularly against Croatia and Mexico. Yet against Argentina, with a final in sight, England fell back into old habits. The manager who promised courage appeared to coach caution into his side when it mattered most.
Which players failed to step up?
Tactics aside, several England players underperformed on the big stage. Harry Kane and Jude Bellingham were unable to influence the game after the formation change, while the defence ultimately cracked under relentless pressure. Sky Sports noted that some players were already defending before the switch, suggesting a collective mental fragility that Tuchel has struggled to eradicate.
Were there mistakes in squad selection?
Tuchel's initial squad raised eyebrows. The omissions of Trent Alexander-Arnold, Harry Maguire, and Cole Palmer were questioned, especially when the latter two had starred in previous tournaments. While Tuchel's selections reached the semi-finals, the lack of depth to change games from the bench was evident against Argentina.
What now for Tuchel and England?
Tuchel has vowed to stay on and retains the FA's backing, with a contract signed in February. But scrutiny will intensify. A third-place play-off against France awaits, followed by a September friendly against Spain at Wembley. Gary Neville has refused to join the pile-on, arguing England's issues predate Tuchel. "I won't lump in on the criticisms," Neville said. "These are the same problems England have had for years." Whether Tuchel can solve them remains the biggest question of all.
Source: Sky Sports