news

England 1-2 Argentina: World Cup 2026 Semi-Final Player Ratings

England suffered late heartbreak against Argentina in the World Cup 2026 semi-final, losing 2-1 despite leading through Anthony Gordon. Enzo Fernandez...

3 min read 10 views
England 1-2 Argentina: World Cup 2026 Semi-Final Player Ratings
Editorial illustration

England's World Cup dream ended in heartbreak as Argentina staged a stunning late comeback to win 2-1 in the semi-final at Atlanta Stadium. Anthony Gordon's second-half opener had England on course for a first final since 1966, but goals from Enzo Fernandez and substitute Lautaro Martinez in the final seven minutes sent the holders through. Here are the player ratings from a dramatic night in Atlanta, as published by The Guardian.

England Player Ratings

England lined up in a 4-2-3-1 formation, with several standout performers in what was ultimately a losing effort.

Jordan Pickford (7): Had little chance with either goal and made a sensational save from Gonzalez, but that will be forgotten now.

Reece James (7): Dominated his flank and justified his recall after injury.

John Stones (7): A rock until the last 10 minutes, when his lack of match sharpness showed.

Marc Guehi (7): Reliable as ever, didn't put a foot wrong and was unlucky to lose.

Djed Spence (8): Won over the doubters with a brilliant display, including a Bobby Moore-esque tackle on Simeone.

Elliot Anderson (7): All-action, but booked for a cynical foul on Lionel Messi.

Declan Rice (6): More like his usual self, but had to be sacrificed as England tried to protect the lead.

Morgan Rogers (7): Preferred in an unusual right-flank role and set up Gordon brilliantly.

Jude Bellingham (6): Fired up but couldn't save England this time, nearly losing his rag in injury time.

Anthony Gordon (8): Came of age in the tournament; his World Cup semi-final goal will live long in the memory.

Harry Kane (5): Launched the long pass for the goal but was otherwise largely anonymous.

Substitutes

Ezri Konsa (5): Slotted into a back three but at fault for Martinez's equaliser.

Dan Burn (5): Third time unlucky after previous nervy cameos.

Nico O'Reilly (5): Couldn't prevent Messi's cross for the winner.

Ivan Toney (6): Introduced far too late to make an impact.

Marcus Rashford (6): Tried to drag England level in stoppage time.

Argentina Player Ratings

Lionel Scaloni's side started 4-3-3 and grew into the game after going behind.

Emiliano Martinez (6): No chance with Gordon's goal; otherwise a spectator.

Nahuel Molina (6): Struggled against the Spence-Gordon combination.

Cristian Romero (8): Squared up to Bellingham early and showed nifty footwork to escape trouble.

Lisandro Martinez (7): Walked a tightrope after an early booking and was unsurprisingly taken off.

Nicolas Tagliafico (5): His error led to Gordon's goal; had his hands full with Rogers.

Leandro Paredes (5): Early reducer on Anderson but couldn't control midfield.

Enzo Fernandez (8): Inches from a spectacular first-half goal before his stunning equaliser.

Alexis Mac Allister (8): Back to his best, hitting both posts in a lively display.

Giuliani Simeone (6): Like father, like son – always involved but missed a clear chance.

Lionel Messi (9): Imperious touches and mazy runs defied his age; deserves to sign off on the biggest stage.

Julian Alvarez (8): Caused problems all afternoon down the left; Messi's heir in waiting.

Substitutes

Nicolas Gonzalez (8): Denied by Pickford but added attacking impetus.

Nicolas Otamendi (7): Still performing at an incredible level for his age.

Gonzalo Montiel (7): A massive upgrade on Molina as Argentina chased the game.

Rodrigo De Paul (8): Surprise omission from the XI, but helped change the game.

Lautaro Martinez (8): Argentina's hero with a brilliant headed winner.

What did you think?

Discussion

Be the first to comment

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this article. Start the conversation!

In this story

Stay Connected

Get your 90min briefing

A sharper football read, tuned to your inbox.

More options 3 topics selected
Personalise
Delivery rhythm

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Logo Quiz
Play Full Game →
Guess this club

Which club is this?

Share this article